ONlwSG

buthaigear m. [ˈb̥u̟-iɡ̊ʲəɾ], [ˈb̥u-iɡ̊ʲəɾ], gen. buthaigeir -[əɾʲ], ‘puffin, Fratercula arctica’. There are four main forms of this word (A–D, below), each with its own variants and/or erroneous spellings: 

On Martin’s form bowger, Coates remarks (1988, 10) that ‘[t]he Gaelic dictionaries have invented some spellings for it like bugaire, budhaigir, budhaid, buthraigear, buigire ... which appear to indicate at least two pronunciation traditions, one with /k/ and one with /k'/, as well as numerous other points of variety’, which perhaps unintentionally implies the spellings are not based on spoken forms. The velar stops are phonemically /ɡ/ and /ɡ´/, not /k/ and /k´/.

under (A) and (B), both non-palatalised and palatalised varieties of the medial velar plosive occur, as well as (although orthographic forms cannot always be trusted) both short and long varieties of the stressed vowel.

A. bugair, buigir; bùgair, bùigir
A 1. bugair, bùgair
(i) bowger (Martin 1698, 91: ‘they use likewise the flesh of a fowl called by them bowger’, 94, 108), bouger (Buchan 1727, 21), bougir (Macaulay 1764, 153) and ’m boucier (Ross c. 1890, which consists of the typescript of a manuscript) are associated specifically with St Kilda; as essentially Scots orthographic forms, it is not clear whether the original Gaelic forms had short or long stressed vowels. Ross’s form is probably a misreading of an original *’m bouger (with aphaerisis of the Gaelic masculine singular article). As part of a concluding list, Ross also notes ‘puffin – bo’, but here the word seems to have been left unfinished by the typist, perhaps with a view to confirming the manuscript form, but never completed.

McDonald (2009, 347) takes Ross’s bo to be intentional.


(ii) bugair (Dwelly 1911).
(iii) buthgair m. (An Stòr-Dàta 1993), which, via an association with SG bùth [b̥u̟ː], [b̥uː] ‘shop’, may intend bùgair.

A 2. buigir, bùigir
(i) buigeir (Henderson 1910, 124); and
(ii) bòigear (MacBain 1896; Dwelly), boigear (Forbes 1905, 322).

B. bugaire, buigire; bùgaire, bùigire
B 1. bugaire, bùgaire
This form is found as bugaire in Forbes (ibid.) and Faclan bhon t-Sluagh^˄ (for Harris).

B 2. buigire, bùigire
(i) buigire [bŭėgʹ-ėr-ȧ] (M^cAlpine 1832: 

Typeset out of alphabetical order after bucull.

St Kilda; CG II, 336: Mingulay; Faclan bhon t-Sluagh^˄: Harris; Forbes ibid., also misspelt as bugire; MacBain, s.v. budhaigir).
(ii) bùigire (MacLennan 1925, s.v. budhaigir; Faclan bhon t-Sluagh^˄: Harris, and [bu̟:ɡʹəɾə], Skye).

C. buthaigear, buthaigir
(with /V̄/ > /V-V/ and hiatus indicated by a digraph: th or dh)
C 1. buthaigear
(with a non-palatalised final)
buthaigear (Henderson ibid.: Barra and Harris; Faclan bhon t-Sluagh^˄, Skye).

C 2. buthaigir
(with a palatalised final)
(i) budhaigir (HSS 1828; Forbes ibid.; Dwelly; MacBain; MacLennan: [boo’ugir]).
(ii) buthaigir (AFB^˄: /bu.ɪgʲɪrʲ/).
(iii) buthaigre (Dwelly; An Stòr-Dàta 1993; AFB^˄: f. /bu.ɪgʲrʲə/, Lewis, Harris and Skye), with metathesis.

C 3. (with epenthetic r)
buthraigear (Forbes ibid.; Henderson ibid.: Barra and Harris).

D. buthaid
(The ending here is perhaps formed on the analogy of the bird name pioghaid /pi.adʲ/ ‘magpie’, cf. also aghaid /a.adʲ/ ‘idem’ and ullaid /uLadʲ/ ‘owl’ (AFB^˄).)
(with hiatus indicated by a digraph: th, dh, gh)
(i) buthaid (Dwelly; Faclan bhon t-Sluagh^˄: South Uist, Lewis, Skye; AFB^˄: /bu.ɪdʲ/, South Uist, Harris, Lewis, Skye).
(ii) budhaid (MacLennan).
(iii) bughaid (An Stòr-Dàta 1993; Faclan bhon t-Sluagh^˄: Lewis).
(iv) bughaide f. (An Stòr-Dàta 1993), apparently a normalised genitive form of (i)–(iii).
(v) bùide (CG II, 335: buite, St Kilda; 

So also Dwelly.

Faclan bhon t-Sluagh^˄: [bu̟:dʹə], ‘but usually buthaid’, Raasay), probably for *bùighde etc., a syncopated form of bughaide etc.
(vi) puthaid (AFB^˄: /pu.adʲ/, North Uist, Lewis, Skye), with /p/ ~ /b/ alternation.
(vii) bugaid (Faclan bhon t-Sluagh^˄: Lewis 

One entry gives ‘puffin’, another quotes rinn e bugaid dheth ‘I killed it outright’ and tha e na bhugaid ann a sud ‘it’s lying stone dead there’. Here, bugaid may be based on Scots bouk ‘carcase’ (SND^˄, s.v. ²bouk), or may be a loan from MScots boukit adj. ‘of large bulk’ (DOST^˄, s.v.), in the sense ‘dead weight’.

), with medial /ɡ/, perhaps under the influence of Scots bowger, bouger ‘puffin’.
(viii) buthaig f. (An Stòr-Dàta 1993), also budhaig (Cunningham 1990, 137), perhaps a normalised dative form of *buthag etc., with its ending based on the suffix -ag, commonly found in bird names, e.g. buidheag ‘yellow hammer’, feannag ‘crow’, curracag ‘lapwing’, or perhaps simply buthaid adapted to buthaig under the influence of such names. Alternatively, it may simply be a truncated form of buthaigear etc.

Mackenzie (1911, 53) suggests buigire means ‘damp fellow’, based on SG buige in the sense ‘dampness, moistness’, but this assumes an original short stressed vowel and seems unlikely to have generated either forms with long stressed vowels or those under (C).

MacBain cross-references bòigear to budhaigir, under which he suggests that budhaigir, buigire and Scots bowger, bouger are (≈) ‘somehow from ON bugr m. “curve”: i.e. “bent-bill?”’. Henderson (ibid.) argues that the form bugaire confirms MacBain’s derivation. Problematically, ON g is a velar fricative in the word bugr. Sommerfelt (1952b, 375), however, takes (C) buthaigear etc. as the primary form, deriving it from an unattested ON *bugakeri, consisting of (?a compound form of) bugr + keri ‘cock, male bird’, as found in ON rjúpkeri ‘cock ptarmigan’, with the loss of ON g between vowels marked by hiatus (cf. ON boga > SG bogha, q.v.) and with intervocalic k yielding SG g regularly.

McDonald (2009, 347) apparently concurs with this thesis, but later (2015a, 122–23) is uncertain.

This assumes that buthaigear later developed into bùigear, with /V̄/ ~ /V-V/ alternation, although it is equally possible that an original ON *bug-keri, with the stem form of bugr, yielded bùigire in the first instance, which then developed into buthaigear.

Lockwood supposes (1963, 56) that budhaigir is of unknown provenance, although he earlier suggests (1961, 66–67) a correspondance between SG buigeir and Far. (Suðuroy) bukari ‘striker’, 

Based on the verb buka in the sense ‘to beat, strike, drub’. The Faroese bird name is found only in Nicolai Mohr’s dictionary MS (Den Nye Kongelige Samling 1287, fol. 64: ‘bugari vid. drunkvuidi’, fol. 84: ‘drunkvujti, s.m. “Søren Peder, Procellaria pelagica”’, but is cited in Svabo 1966, as Lockwood (1968, 102) notes. A form bugari would suggest a derivation from the verb buga ‘to bend, bow, curve’.

although the latter refers to the stormy petrel; however, he later claims (1968, 102–03) that Far. bukari has no affinity with either Scots bowger, bouger (which he takes to be borrowed from Scottish Gaelic) or SG bugaire etc. Later still, he points out (1976, 277–78) that Far. bukari is of no great age and states that he is disposed to believe that SG buigeir is a neologism comparable SG to amhas ‘gannet’ (q.v.), and suggests (1984, 34) that SG bùgair may be an adaptation of ON búkr m. in the sense ‘belly’, using the Scottish Gaelic agentive suffix -air.

However, Far. buka ‘to strike etc.’ is related to Nn. boka ‘to soften by pounding, dig, root’ (Torp 1992, s.v. bŏka, with a long stressed vowel) and Scots bok (Shetland) [bok], [bōk], [bō^ək] ‘to squeeze, press down with small jerks, stamp, trample’ (Jakobsen 1928, s.v.). A Scots (Shetland) *boker 

With the agentive suffix -[ər], the equivalent of Far. -ari.

*[bokər], *[bōkər], *[bō^əkər] (according to dialect) would seem to provide the phonetic basis for SG (A) bugair, buigir/bùgair, bùigir, (B) bugaire, buigire/bùgaire, bùigire, with its alternative suffix, and (C) buthaigear, via /V̄/ ~ /V-V/ alternation (while (D) buthaid is probably an analogous formation). Scots bowger, bouger and, via ‘reverse spelling’, bulker 

Lockwood (1984, 35–36) takes bulker to represent SG *bulgair, based on bulg in the sense ‘belly’, comparing the alternative name builgeun, which he takes to mean ‘belly-bird’ (< bulg + eun ‘bird’). However, builgeun may simply arise from bu(i)lg in the sense ‘bulge, blister’, with reference to the bird’s beak; cf. Scots coulterneb ‘coulter[-shaped] beak’.

may indeed derive from SG bugair, buigir or bùgair, bùigir, although it is superficially reminiscent of *boker. The sense of Scots *boker may be ‘the drubber, the stamper, the tramper’, perhaps from some of the ways the puffin uses its feet, e.g. to shovel away soil in digging burrows and preparing nests; to welcome arrivals by stomping its feet; and to run across the surface of the water before take-off. Scots *boker, then, may be cognate with Far. bukari.